top of page

Renovating a Farmhouse in Le Marche: Exposed Stone, Brick or Render?

Writer: Paolo Vigoni
Paolo Vigoni
6 days ago
13 min read

How to choose materials, colours and finishes when restoring a traditional farmhouse in Le Marche, preserving its architectural character while improving comfort and energy performance.


“Do you think we should leave the stonework exposed or render the whole building?”


It is one of the questions that sooner or later arises when someone buys an old farmhouse and starts imagining what it could become after renovation.


The answer, however, is not quite so straightforward. More importantly, it should not be the first decision to make.


Farmhouse restored in the Verdicchio hills, south elevation
Restoration of a farmhouse in the Verdicchio hills

A traditional farmhouse is not a new house for which you simply have to choose an external finish. It is a building with a history of its own, shaped by materials, construction techniques and alterations that have often accumulated over many decades. Stone, brick, render and later repairs all tell part of the story of the place where it was built and the people who once lived there.


Before deciding whether to leave a wall exposed or cover it with render, it is essential to understand what you are dealing with, which features deserve to be preserved and what kind of result you want to achieve.

In my experience of designing and restoring farmhouses across Le Marche, I have learned that there is no single aesthetic solution that works for every building. There are, however, choices that can enhance a farmhouse's identity and others that risk erasing it.


Before buying a farmhouse: look at the materials, not just the view


When viewing a farmhouse for sale, it is easy to fall in love with the landscape, the setting, the shape of the building and perhaps a beautiful stone façade.


These are all important features, but it is also worth paying attention to details that might initially seem less significant: the type of masonry, the colour of the materials, variations in the wall construction, rendered sections, later additions and the condition of the surfaces.


A stone wall is not necessarily more interesting than a rendered one. Nor is a wall made up of different materials automatically a defect that needs to be concealed.


San Vittore farmhouse, exterior view
San Vittore farmhouse

In fact, the differences between one section and another may reveal the various stages in the building's history: an extension, an additional storey, a repair or an alteration carried out at a later date.


These features should be understood before the renovation is designed. The aim is not to preserve indiscriminately everything that exists, but to distinguish what is worth enhancing from what genuinely needs intervention.


My first piece of advice, therefore, is not to choose a farmhouse solely for the image you imagine it could have after renovation. It is equally important to understand the qualities it already possesses and what can realistically be preserved.


Exposed stone: every area has its own identity


When people talk about stone farmhouses in Le Marche, they often picture a fairly uniform image: a country house with natural stone walls, perhaps with a few brick details.


In reality, a short journey inland can reveal striking differences in materials, colours and building traditions.


In the inland areas of Le Marche, around Staffolo, Cupramontana, Apiro and Cingoli, sandstone is widely used. It is a warm-coloured stone, often a straw yellow, sometimes featuring bluish-grey elements.


Exterior view of the restored farmhouse in the Verdicchio hills
Verdicchio hills: restoration of a farmhouse

Moving towards Castelplanio, Montecarotto and Serra San Quirico, the stone generally becomes lighter in colour. Around Arcevia, it can be almost white, with a greater presence of materials locally known as scoglio bianco, or white rock.


These are not simply differences in colour. The texture of the stone, the size of the individual pieces, the way they were worked and the techniques used to lay them also vary.


A stone façade is not defined by the material alone. Its appearance depends greatly on the arrangement of the stones, their dimensions, the depth of the joints, the type of pointing and the presence of cornerstones, lintels and window surrounds.


Exterior detail of the farmhouse restored in the Verdicchio hills
A detail of the farmhouse

A wall built with regular, carefully squared stones will have a completely different character from one made up of smaller, irregular pieces.


Pointing can also transform the overall appearance. Deep, prominent joints create a very different effect from more discreet workmanship, where the mortar complements the stonework without becoming the dominant feature.


Stone alone does not define a façade: the arrangement of the elements, the depth of the joints and the quality of the workmanship are what give it character.


Restored farmhouse in the Verdicchio hills, exterior
Restoration of a farmhouse in the Verdicchio hills

Exposed brick: a long-standing tradition in the hills of Le Marche


In the hilly and lowland areas closer to the Adriatic coast, brick has played an important role in both rural and urban architecture.


The availability of local clay and the presence of traditional brick kilns encouraged a building tradition in which brick was not simply an inexpensive material, but an essential element of the area's architectural identity.


A look at the historic centres of Filottrano, Montefano, Montecassiano, Macerata and Jesi is enough to appreciate how much brick has contributed to the built landscape of these areas.


Exterior of a renovated farmhouse in Le Marche
Renovated farmhouse in Le Marche

Brick can also play an important role in farmhouse restoration. Whenever possible, I prefer to use reclaimed bricks, as they offer a variety of colours and textures that are difficult to reproduce with new materials.


Their shades range from pale yellow to red, with orange and brown tones in between. These variations depend on the characteristics of the clay and the firing process.


The result is a surface that is never perfectly uniform, where each brick contributes to the overall texture.


Tre Gelsi farmhouse in Cingoli, exposed brick detail
Tre Gelsi farmhouse, Cingoli

Here, too, however, choosing attractive bricks is not enough. The quality of the finished wall depends on the laying pattern, the arrangement of the bricks and, above all, the pointing.


The colour, texture, depth and finish of the joints can make a façade look balanced or excessively patterned. Mortar that is too light or too dark, for example, can significantly alter the appearance of the entire wall.


Preserving original masonry: not everything needs to look new


When working on a farmhouse, the first option to consider is generally the conservation and restoration of the original masonry, naturally after checking its condition and its compatibility with the proposed project.


A stone or brick wall that has stood for decades, or perhaps centuries, should not be covered or replaced simply because it lacks the perfectly uniform appearance of a contemporary building.


Traces of time, variations in colour and irregularities in the masonry can all contribute to its architectural value.



EP farmhouse in Ostra before renovation
EP farmhouse in Ostra: before the works

This does not mean that every material must be preserved at all costs. There may be structural problems, moisture issues, instability or previous alterations that are incompatible with the original masonry. In such cases, the most appropriate solution must be assessed carefully.


The starting point, however, should always be an understanding of the building, rather than the desire to make every surface look the same.


EP farmhouse in Ostra after renovation
EP farmhouse in Ostra: after completion

What if the farmhouse has mixed masonry?


This is a fairly common situation. A façade may have one section in stone, another in brick and yet another covered with render.


These differences are often the result of extensions, alterations and repairs carried out at different times. They are not necessarily mistakes or features that need to be concealed.


In fact, the combination of different materials can be an important part of the building's character.


San Vittore farmhouse, exterior view of the complex
San Vittore farmhouse

Architecture is not always at its best when everything is uniform. Sometimes it is precisely the contrast between different materials that gives a farmhouse its authenticity.


Naturally, it is important to understand which elements have genuine value and how they can be incorporated into the project. Leaving everything exposed without an overall assessment can produce a result that is just as confusing as covering every surface indiscriminately.


Render: a design choice, not a fallback solution


Not every farmhouse needs to have exposed stone or brick façades.


Rendered walls have always been part of traditional rural architecture in Le Marche. Render can be the most appropriate solution when the original masonry has no particular features worth highlighting, when different materials are present or when the design calls for a simpler architectural composition.

In my view, the issue is not render itself, but how it is applied and finished.

It is often assumed that good-quality render should be perfectly smooth, regular and uniform. This may be appropriate for certain types of contemporary architecture, but it is not always suitable for restoring a rural building.


Casa A&D, exterior façade
Casa A&D

Personally, I often prefer hand-applied finishes, with subtle irregularities and a less artificially perfect surface.

This is not about accepting poor workmanship. It is a deliberate design choice: creating a finish that is consistent with the character of the building, rather than turning an old farmhouse into something that looks like a newly built suburban villa.

Light also plays an important role in how rendered surfaces are perceived. A slightly textured finish reacts differently throughout the day compared with a perfectly smooth wall.

The finish should therefore be considered alongside the colour and architectural details, rather than treated as the final operation to be decided on site.


The colour of the render can completely change a farmhouse


Colour is one of the elements that has the greatest influence on the final result.


The wrong shade can make even a carefully designed renovation feel out of place. Conversely, a well-balanced colour can enhance a building without the need for additional decorative features.


For traditional farmhouses in Le Marche, I often find warm, natural tones particularly effective: ivory, beige, straw yellow, earthy colours and slightly pinkish shades.


There is, however, no universal colour palette that works for every building.


The colour should be considered in relation to any exposed stone or brick, the roof, the window frames, the surrounding landscape and, above all, the natural light of the location.


Tre Gelsi farmhouse in Cingoli, exterior
Tre Gelsi farmhouse, Cingoli

A shade that looks balanced on a sample can appear quite different when applied to a large wall exposed to direct sunlight.

For this reason, it is always preferable to prepare sample patches directly on the building and observe them under different lighting conditions.

Details matter too: window sills, lintels, window surrounds, plinths and cornices should all be considered as part of the same architectural composition.

There is no need to highlight every single element with a different colour. Often, the quality of a façade lies precisely in the ability to work with a limited palette of well-coordinated materials and tones.

Render and external wall insulation: what changes?


When renovating a farmhouse, the choice of external finish may also be influenced by the need to improve the building's energy performance.

If an external wall insulation system is planned, the outer finish will generally consist of a render applied over the insulation system.

Different surface effects can be achieved through the grain size of the finishing coat: typically 1.0, 1.5, 2.0 or 3.0 mm.

A coarser grain produces a more textured surface, while a finer one generally creates a more uniform appearance. In either case, the result is different from a traditional hand-applied render.


Casa A&D, façade detail
Casa A&D

The finish must be coordinated with the design of the openings, window sills, plinths, any decorative mouldings and all the other elements that define the façade.


But there is an even more important question: how can you improve energy efficiency without losing an attractive original stone wall?


It is not always possible to reconcile these two objectives completely. A continuous external insulation system can significantly improve the building envelope's thermal performance, but it also covers the existing masonry.

If the stone or brickwork is an architectural feature worth preserving, other options need to be considered, such as internal wall insulation or solutions specifically designed for the building in question.

Internal insulation, however, is not automatically a straightforward option. Thermal bridges, the characteristics of the existing masonry, moisture behaviour and the risk of interstitial condensation all need to be carefully assessed.

It is also important not to confuse the thermal mass of a stone wall with its insulating capacity. A massive wall can provide good thermal inertia, but that does not necessarily mean it has an adequate thermal transmittance.

The right solution must be identified through an assessment of the building's energy and hygrothermal performance, taking architectural conservation, comfort and technical feasibility into account.


Can exposed stone and render be combined on the same façade?


Absolutely. Exposed stone and render are not necessarily mutually exclusive options.


In some cases, the most balanced solution is precisely to retain both, giving each material a specific role within the architectural composition.


For example, you could:


  • preserve the stonework on the ground floor and render the upper sections;

  • leave a particularly distinctive brick façade exposed while rendering the others;

  • enhance an original stone wall while rendering surfaces made up of different materials;

  • retain selected stone elements, such as cornerstones, lintels or sections of masonry, and integrate them with rendered surfaces.


The choice of colours also requires careful consideration.


Exterior of the Verdicchio hills farmhouse restoration
Restoration of a farmhouse in the Verdicchio hills

Straw-yellow sandstone can work well with warm ivory, beige or earthy tones. Lighter stones can be paired with delicate shades or stronger contrasts in the window frames and metalwork.


Reclaimed bricks, with their shades of yellow, red and brown, generally work well alongside neutral, muted render colours.

There are no universal recipes. What matters is that the materials, colours and details contribute to a coherent result without competing with one another.


How much does it cost to leave stonework exposed rather than render it?


This is a perfectly reasonable question, particularly for anyone considering buying a farmhouse and trying to estimate the overall renovation budget.

There is, however, no general rule stating that exposed stone is always more expensive than render, or vice versa.

The cost depends first and foremost on the condition of the existing walls and the type of work required.

A stone wall that is already in good condition may only need cleaning and localised repairs to the joints. A badly deteriorated wall, on the other hand, may require extensive and specialist work.

Exposed brick can also involve significant costs when reclaimed materials are used, as each brick may need to be selected, cleaned and laid with particular care.

Render may initially appear to be the less expensive option, but its cost varies depending on the preparation of the substrate, the type of mortar, the application technique and whether a thermal insulation system is included.

To compare the alternatives properly, it is important to consider not just the cost of the final finish, but the entire sequence of work needed to achieve the desired result.


Solution

Main characteristics

What to consider

Exposed stone

Texture and a strong connection with local building traditions

Condition of the stone, joints, moisture and restoration work

Exposed brick

Colour, texture and local construction heritage

Quality of the bricks, reclaimed materials, laying and pointing

Traditional render

Flexibility in colour and architectural composition

Wall preparation, mortar and finish

Render over external insulation

Combines thermal insulation with an external finish

Insulation system, architectural details and thermal bridges


Future maintenance should also be taken into account. Exposed masonry requires attention to the condition of the joints, water ingress and any signs of deterioration. Render may require local repairs or renewal of the finish, depending on the building's exposure and the materials used.

The best choice is not necessarily the one that costs less today, but the one that responds to the building's needs and the overall aims of the project.


What if the farmhouse needs to be demolished and rebuilt?


There are situations in which preserving the existing building is not technically or economically viable.


This may be the case, for example, when a building has severe structural problems and the cost of restoration would be unsustainable or would not achieve the required objectives.


n such circumstances, where planning regulations and the site's conditions allow it, demolition and reconstruction may need to be considered.

This does not mean abandoning the relationship with local building traditions.


Entrance of the Tre Gelsi farmhouse in Cingoli, rebuilt with exposed brick, timber and steel
Tre Gelsi farmhouse: the entrance

The Tre Gelsi project, built in the hills around Cingoli, is an example. The original farmhouse had serious structural problems, and the cost of seismic strengthening would have been prohibitive. Demolition and reconstruction were therefore chosen, allowing the spaces and characteristics of the building to be completely rethought.

The design did not attempt simply to reproduce the old farmhouse. Instead, it reinterpreted elements of rural architecture through a contemporary language, using materials such as exposed brick, timber and steel.


Tre Gelsi holiday home in Cingoli
Tre Gelsi holiday home, Cingoli

The result brings together the memory of the place, contemporary living requirements and a new interpretation of rural architecture.

I believe this is an important approach: when it is no longer possible to preserve a building physically, it is still possible to maintain a meaningful relationship with its context and local building culture.


What is the best choice when renovating a farmhouse?


The decision between exposed stone, brick and render cannot be reduced to an aesthetic preference that applies to every situation.

It depends on the building, its original materials, the condition of the walls, energy requirements, the available budget and the architectural result you want to achieve.

Before making a decision, it is therefore advisable to:

  1. understand the farmhouse's history and construction characteristics;

  2. assess the condition of the masonry and identify any deterioration;

  3. identify the features that are worth preserving;

  4. evaluate structural and energy requirements;

  5. define materials, colours and finishes as part of an overall design;

  6. estimate costs by taking all the necessary work into account.

These are issues best addressed before construction begins and, whenever possible, while you are still deciding whether to buy the property.

A farmhouse may have enormous potential, but what you imagine doing with it does not always correspond to what the building can realistically accommodate.

This is why I believe that restoring a farmhouse should begin with a design project, not with the choice of a finish.


Restoration does not mean making everything new, uniform and perfect. It means giving a new life to something that already has its own identity.



Frequently asked questions about farmhouse renovation


Is it better to leave the stone exposed or render a farmhouse?


It depends on the characteristics of the building. If the original masonry is in good condition and has architectural value, preserving and restoring it may be the most appropriate option. If, on the other hand, the walls are made up of heterogeneous materials, are deteriorated or have no particular features worth highlighting, render may be a more suitable solution. The decision should be made after assessing the building and defining the renovation project.


How much does it cost to restore an exposed stone façade?


The cost depends on the condition of the masonry, the quality of the stone, the state of the joints and the work required. A façade in good condition may need only limited repairs, while a deteriorated wall may require cleaning, repointing and more complex restoration work. Each building therefore needs to be assessed individually.


Can external wall insulation be installed on a stone farmhouse?


Yes, but it is important to assess whether external insulation is compatible with the preservation of the masonry. A conventional external insulation system covers the stone and changes the appearance of the façade. If the aim is to retain the original stonework, alternative solutions such as internal wall insulation can be considered, with careful attention to thermal bridges and the moisture behaviour of the walls.


Can exposed stone and render be combined?


Yes. Combining the two can enhance the original features of a farmhouse, for example by preserving a significant section of masonry while rendering the other surfaces. The choice should follow a clear architectural rationale rather than simply alternating different materials for decorative effect.


Which render colours work best for farmhouses in Le Marche?


Warm, natural shades are often particularly effective, including ivory, beige, straw yellow and earthy tones. The choice should nevertheless take into account the existing stone or brickwork, the roof, the window frames, the surrounding landscape and the natural light. It is advisable to test sample colours directly on the façades before making a final decision.

When should you consult an architect?

It is advisable to involve an architect during the property assessment stage, before purchasing the farmhouse or, at the very least, before starting any building work. A preliminary assessment helps establish the building's potential, identify possible constraints and determine whether the intended alterations are feasible. This allows aesthetic, technical and financial decisions to be considered as part of a coordinated design project.

Comments


bottom of page